Get 15% OFF your First online order! Use code YAYAS15 at checkout.
Our menu
Quesitos (cream cheese)
A rotating taste of Puerto Rico made fresh at Central Market in York. Our offerings change throughout the week, so availability varies daily — but here's the full range of what we make!
Bavarian Cream Pastry
Guava Pastry
Guava & Cream Cheese Quesitos
Coconut Kiss
Polvorones
Fresh Pastries
$3.50- 4.00 each
Fresh Donuts
Flaky puff pastry filled with sweet cream cheese
Quesito with a ribbon of tropical guava
Light, custard-filled and golden
Sweet coconut in a delicate pastry
Buttery pastry with bright guava filling
Crumbly Puerto Rican shortbread cookies
Made fresh daily
Strawberry Nutella Pastry
A Yaya fan's favorite pastry
Tres Leches
Crème Brûlée
Bread Pudding
Basque Cheesecake
Flan de Queso
Almond Pound Cake
Signature Desserts
$5.00 - $6.00 each
Lemon Pound Cake
Sponge cake soaked in three milks, our signature
Burnt-top, creamy spanish-style cheesecake
Silky custard with a torched sugar crust
Cream-cheese flan with caramel
Warm, spiced, and rich
Moist Puerto Rican-style ponqué
Bright and buttery
Pistachio Pound Cake
Meaty Roll-Ups
Cantinflas Tacos
Grandma's Plate
Mallorca Sandwich
Tripleta Sandwich
Savory Menu
$4.00
$7.00
$12.00
$8.00
$15.00
Savory pastry rolled around seasoned meat
Sweet Puerto Rican bread, Egg Ham and Cheese
The classic PR triple-meat sandwich
Yaya's take, seasoned and loaded
A hearty plate of home-style Puerto Rican cooking
Yaya's Tropi-Duo
1 pastry + 12oz piña colada
PR Signature Pack
4 signature dessert cups or slices
Pastry Lovers Pack
5 fresh pastries
The 787 Sweet Pack
3 dessert cups or slices + 3 fresh pastries
Sweet Combos
$8.00
$18.00
$16.00
$24.00
Ready to Order?
Pickup:
Order directly through our shop for pickup at the Central Market or pre-order here!
Our menu rotates and availability varies daily — if there's something specific you're after, message us to confirm.
Delivery:
Find us on:
